New here? Get 15% off your first order.See how it works

Nursing questions

Advocacy Paper Essay

A four to five page paper applying a bioethical decision making model to a clinical situation in which a registered nurse should advocate for a patient, closing on nursing advocacy and the nurse's role as patient advocate.

Editorial process

Last reviewed · August 7, 2026

01

The model is the structure, gaps and all

The model is the paper's structure, and the instruction is explicit: *address each section of the model in your paper*. That is a spine, not a suggestion, and it means the marker can find each step by name or note its absence. Use the model's own language for your headings — define the dilemma, identify the medical facts, identify the non-medical facts, separate facts from assumptions, identify the decision makers, review the ethical principles, define alternatives, follow up — and the paper becomes checkable rather than merely readable. Four to five pages across roughly eight substantive sections is half a page each, which is enough for a real analysis and not enough for a literature review, so resist the urge to explain the model before applying it. Labelling the sections with the model's own vocabulary also makes it obvious to you, while drafting, which step is still empty.

Read the numbered list carefully, because the copy you have been given is imperfect and pretending otherwise causes trouble. The steps run one to six, then jump to eight — there is no step seven — and step six ends with an orphan fragment reading *all of the answers*, which is the tail of a sentence that did not survive. Steps two and three are also one idea rather than two, since the third is a reminder that diagnosis and prognosis count as medical facts. Cover every step that is actually present, treat the separation of facts from assumptions thoroughly since that is where the break occurs, and if the missing step matters to your grade, ask rather than invent one. A paper that silently renumbers to eleven has fabricated a requirement. Noting the gap in a sentence is safer than either ignoring it or filling it, and it shows the marker that the list was read rather than skimmed.

The ethical principles step is selective and most papers treat it as a checklist. The brief names six — beneficence, nonmaleficence, veracity, fidelity, autonomy and justice — and then asks you to *review which ones and why they apply to this particular case*. Naming all six and defining each is the wrong answer: it demonstrates recall rather than judgement. Choose the two or three that are actually in tension in your scenario and argue them against each other. In an incomplete informed consent case, veracity and autonomy pull one way while a clinician's beneficence pulls the other, and the whole ethical difficulty lives in that conflict. A principle that is not in tension with another one does not need a paragraph. The same applies to the alternatives step, where the benefits and burdens are only interesting if the two options genuinely favour different principles.

The clinical situation can be actual or hypothetical, and hypothetical is usually the better choice for a reason the brief does not spell out: a real case brings confidentiality obligations with it, and an anonymised real case often loses the detail the model needs. What the model demands is unusually specific — non-medical facts including culture, religion, economics, the existence of an advance directive and verbal preferences the patient expressed, plus external influences including organisational policy, state law, practice acts and codes of ethics. Build the scenario with those slots already in mind. A case that does not specify whether an advance directive exists cannot answer step four, and inventing one halfway through the paper is visible. Writing the scenario last, after listing what each step will demand of it, is faster than writing it first and patching it afterwards.

Two requirements sit outside the model and are separately marked. The conclusion is not a summary: the brief asks you to *conclude with a discussion of nursing advocacy in the clinical setting and the nurse's role as a patient advocate*, which is a general argument about the role rather than a recap of your case. That is where your outside sources earn their place, because the advocacy literature defines the role in terms your case can be measured against. And the sourcing rule is narrow: one to two scholarly sources *other than your text*, with the text also cited — so the assigned reading has to appear, and two well-used articles beat six listed ones. Placing the advocacy sources in the conclusion rather than scattering them through the case analysis also keeps the case in your own voice, which the first step asks for.

Step in the modelThe version that under-performsWhat the step is actually asking
Define the dilemmaRestating the clinical factsThe conflict, in your own words, stated so another reader grasps it fast
Medical factsThe full historyOnly the facts the dilemma turns on, including diagnosis and prognosis
Non-medical factsThe patient was elderlyCulture, religion, economics, advance directive, stated preferences
External influencesEthics matter in nursingNamed policy, statute, practice act or code provision
Facts versus assumptionsSkipped entirelyWhat you know against what the team inferred
Decision makersThe doctor decidesCapacity, surrogate, and how that surrogate was selected
Ethical principlesAll six, definedThe two or three in genuine tension, argued against each other
AlternativesThe right course of actionTwo options with benefits and burdens for each
Follow-upOmittedHow the chosen alternative would be carried out and reviewed

Likely learning objectives

  • Apply a structured decision model to a clinical ethical problem.
  • Separate medical facts, non-medical facts and assumptions.
  • Select ethical principles by relevance rather than by recall.
  • Distinguish a case analysis from a discussion of a professional role.

Assignment instructions

Read the full question

Review every instruction before using the planning guidance that follows.

Choose a patient-care situation in which the RN should intervene and advocate for the patient. An example of such a situation might be when a patient has not been given complete informed consent. Include the following in your paper: Describe the clinical situation concisely and descriptively. It can be an actual situation or a hypothetical one. Apply the Bioethical Decision Making to the specific clinical ethical situation that you choose. Address each section of the model in your paper. Bioethical Decision Making Model 1. Define the dilemma: Use your own words to describe the problem. State it in a way that others can quickly understand your dilemma. 2. Identify the medical facts: Describe the facts that are relevant to the dilemma. 3. Remember that the diagnosis and prognosis are medical facts. 4. Identify the non-medical facts (patient and family, external influences): a. Patient and family facts such as culture, religion, social, economic, the existence of an Advance Healthcare Directive, verbal preferences made by the patient, how the patient lived his/her life. b. Those that you discuss should be relevant to the situation. 5. External influences include: organizational policies, federal and state laws, practice acts, code of ethics. These should be relevant to the situation. 6. For both step 2 or 3, separate the facts from the assumptions: Sometimes all healthcare professionals allow assumptions to guide their decision-making. These must be identified so that these assumptions do not interfere with the process. all of the answers. 8. Identify the decision makers: Is the patient an adult competent to make their own choices? Is the patient a child who is old enough to have a say in the decision. If the patient cannot make their own decision, who is the decision maker? How was this person selected? 9. Review the underlying ethical principles: Review which ones and why they apply to this particular case: beneficence, nonmaleficience, veracity, fidelity, autonomy and justice. 10. Define alternatives: One-Way to proceed may be apparent at this point. However, sometimes there are different choices. They should be addressed identifying the benefits and burdens for doing one thing versus the other. 11. Follow-up: Define the process to be used with the chosen alternative. Reference Source: Levine-Ariff, J. & Groh, D.H. (1990). Creating an Ethical Environment. Nurse managers\’ bookshelf a quarterly series: 2:1. Baltimore, Maryland: Williams & Wilkins. 41-61. Conclude with a discussion of nursing advocacy in the clinical setting and the nurse’s role as a patient advocate. Your paper should be 4-5 pages. You must reference and cite 1-2 scholarly sources other than your text. Include a title page and a reference page to cite your text and adhere to APA formatting. Content is clear, thorough, and organized effectively. Main points are well supported. Meets all of the criteria of the written assignment. Writing flows smoothly from one idea to another. Writer has taken pains to assist the reader in following the logic of the ideas expressed. The required number of scholarly references is used and cited skillfully throughout the paper. The assignment consistently follows current APA format and is free from errors in formatting, citation, and references. No grammatical, spelling, or punctuation errors. All sources are cited and referenced correctly in APA.

02

Everything the advocacy paper must contain

  1. 01A 4 to 5 page paper in APA format with a title page and reference page.
  2. 02A concise, descriptive account of the clinical situation, real or hypothetical.
  3. 03Every section of the Bioethical Decision Making Model, applied to that situation.
  4. 04The medical facts, the non-medical facts and the external influences.
  5. 05Facts separated from assumptions.
  6. 06The decision makers, and how a surrogate was selected if one applies.
  7. 07The ethical principles that apply, with reasons.
  8. 08Alternatives with their benefits and burdens, and a follow-up process.
  9. 09A closing discussion of nursing advocacy and the nurse's role as patient advocate.
  10. 10One to two scholarly sources beyond the course text, with the text also cited.
03

From the scenario to the advocacy conclusion

01

The situation, built to fit the model

A concise scenario that already contains the cultural, economic, directive and policy details later steps demand.

What the assessor is likely looking for

A case that can actually be analysed.

02

The dilemma in your own words

The conflict stated so a reader grasps it immediately, not the clinical history restated.

What the assessor is likely looking for

Step one, which is about framing rather than description.

03

Facts, non-medical facts and influences

Relevant medical facts, then patient and family factors, then policy, law, practice acts and codes.

What the assessor is likely looking for

Named external influences rather than a general nod to ethics.

04

What is known against what is assumed

The assumptions the team is carrying, identified so they do not drive the decision.

What the assessor is likely looking for

The step most often skipped entirely.

05

Who decides, and which principles collide

Capacity and surrogate selection, then the two or three principles in genuine tension.

What the assessor is likely looking for

Judgement rather than recall.

06

Alternatives, follow-up, and the advocacy role

Two courses of action weighed, a follow-up process, then a general discussion of the nurse as patient advocate.

What the assessor is likely looking for

A conclusion that is an argument, not a summary.

04

Where the outside sources actually belong

Recommended databases

  • The assigned course text
  • CINAHL and PubMed
  • Professional codes of ethics
  • Academic bioethics teaching resources

Search sequence

  1. 1.Read the model steps first and list what facts they will demand, because that list is the specification for the scenario you are about to build.
  2. 2.Search the advocacy literature for the conclusion rather than for the case, since the closing section is the part that needs external sources and the case does not.
  3. 3.Find a definition of the principles you intend to use from a teaching resource rather than a dictionary, so the tension between them is described rather than assumed.
  4. 4.Check the code of ethics for the specific provision your external influences step names, since a general citation will not satisfy that step.
05

Advocacy research, the Code, and the bioethics topics

These are authoritative starting points, not a ready-made bibliography. A qualified reviewer must confirm that each source fits the assignment and supports the claim beside which it is cited.

Patient advocacy in nursing: A concept analysis

Nursing Ethics, via PubMed · 2019

Review before citing

A concept analysis identifying the attributes of patient advocacy — safeguarding autonomy, acting on the patient's behalf, and championing social justice in care. This gives the closing section a defined structure, so the discussion of the nurse's role rests on attributes rather than on assertion.

Review before citing

What practising nurses say advocacy consists of: protecting patients, being the patient's voice, ensuring quality care and educating. Useful because the brief asks specifically about advocacy in the clinical setting, and this reports it from inside that setting rather than from theory.

Ethics and Human Rights in Nursing | ANA

American Nurses Association · 2024

Review before citing

The professional code and the position statements that sit under it. Cite a specific provision in the external influences step, since the model asks for codes of ethics as an influence on the case and a general reference does not identify which obligation applies.

Ethics in Medicine | UW Department of Bioethics & Humanities

University of Washington Department of Bioethics and Humanities · 2024

Review before citing

Topic articles on informed consent, decision-making capacity, surrogate decision-making and the principles themselves. Use it for the decision makers step, which asks how a surrogate was selected — a question with an actual answer in law and practice rather than a matter of opinion.

06

Before the advocacy paper is submitted

Common mistakes

  • Explaining the model at length before applying it, in a paper with no room for that.
  • Silently renumbering the model to hide the gap in the list as supplied.
  • Merging steps two and three, or dropping the separation of facts from assumptions.
  • Naming and defining all six ethical principles instead of selecting the ones in tension.
  • Describing a scenario too thin to answer the non-medical facts step.
  • Adding details to the scenario mid-paper once a step demands them.
  • Answering the decision makers step with a job title instead of a capacity assessment.
  • Writing a conclusion that summarises the case rather than discussing the advocacy role.
  • Citing outside sources but not the course text, which the brief requires.

Submission checklist

  • Each model step present in the brief has its own labelled section.
  • The scenario supplies every fact the later steps need.
  • Assumptions are named separately from facts.
  • Capacity and surrogate selection are addressed explicitly.
  • Two or three principles are argued against each other, not six defined.
  • At least two alternatives appear, each with benefits and burdens.
  • A follow-up process is described.
  • The conclusion discusses the advocacy role generally.
  • The course text and one to two other scholarly sources are cited in APA.

Use this guide to plan and review your own work. Follow your institution's rules and read Brinevia's academic-integrity policy.

Written by

Everett Voss

MA, Education

assignment interpretation and research-methods coaching across disciplines

Everett leads the Brinevia editorial desk. He works on how assignment briefs are read — what a rubric is actually asking for, and where students most often answer a different question than the one set.

Reviewed by

Dr. Julian Merriweather

PhD, Rhetoric & Composition

Argumentation and thesis development

Julian teaches first-year composition and directs a university writing center. He reviews Brinevia guides for argumentative soundness and citation accuracy.

Want feedback on your plan before you draft?

Get help interpreting the brief, checking your evidence strategy, and strengthening your outline while keeping the work your own.

Get assignment guidance
Start your order