New here? Get 15% off your first order.See how it works

Nursing questions

Anyone Who Had a Heart: A Case Study in Physiology

A twenty-question progressive case following two newborns, where the differential question repeats on purpose — each time after new signs appear — and answering it identically each time misses the whole exercise.

Editorial process

Last reviewed · August 8, 2026

01

Why does the diagnosis question repeat four times?

The question that looks like a copy-paste error is actually the structure of the whole case. *What are the possible diagnoses for Brianna's condition at this time?* recurs at questions 8, 9, 16 and 19, each time after new signs have been revealed, and the phrase **at this time** is doing the work. This is a progressive-disclosure case: you are meant to commit to a differential on incomplete information, then revise it as vital signs, auscultation findings and new symptoms arrive. Answering all four with the same list defeats the exercise. Each iteration should be visibly narrower than the last, and you should say what the new information ruled in or out — that reasoning trail is what is being assessed, not the final answer. Number your differentials by question so the narrowing is visible on the page rather than implied.

Questions 1 to 3 are the physiology foundation and everything downstream depends on getting them right. The fetal heart differs from the adult's by three shunts: the **ductus venosus**, bypassing the liver; the **foramen ovale**, passing blood from right atrium to left and so bypassing the lungs; and the **ductus arteriosus**, shunting from pulmonary artery to aorta for the same reason. Pulmonary circulation is reduced in the fetus because the lungs are fluid-filled and non-functional, so pulmonary vascular resistance is high and blood takes the path of least resistance through the shunts. And yes, 130-160 is normal — the accepted fetal range runs roughly 110-160 beats per minute. Each shunt also closes for a specific reason after the first breath, and knowing why makes the pathological versions easier to reason about later.

Cyanosis is the hinge of the case, and the question *would you be alarmed that Brianna has cyanosis and Christopher does not* is asking you to reason about a comparison rather than describe a sign. Cyanosis is bluish discolouration caused by increased deoxygenated haemoglobin in the circulation, and in a newborn it points toward a right-to-left shunt or an obstructive or mixing lesion. Two babies, same environment, one cyanotic — that difference is a finding, and it makes an isolated neonatal problem far more likely than a shared external cause. The faster breathing rate follows directly: tachypnoea is the compensatory response to hypoxaemia, and it is one of the presenting features of critical congenital heart disease. Note too that Christopher functions as the control in this case, which is unusual and worth using explicitly.

The auscultation questions build a vocabulary you then apply. The first heart sound is produced by closure of the atrioventricular valves and the second by closure of the semilunar valves; a murmur is turbulent flow made audible; and murmurs do differ in timing, quality and location in ways that correlate with the underlying lesion. So a whirring sound *between* the lub and the dub is systolic, and that placement is diagnostic information rather than description — it points toward flow across a septal defect or through an obstructed outflow tract. In tetralogy of Fallot, for instance, the murmur is a harsh systolic ejection sound best heard at the left mid-to-upper sternal border, and its intensity tracks the degree of obstruction. Locating a murmur on the chest wall is as informative as its timing, so give both whenever the case supplies them.

For the differential itself, work from a classification rather than a list of names, because the case gives you exactly the information a classification uses. Critical congenital heart disease divides into right heart obstructive lesions (pulmonary or tricuspid atresia, tetralogy of Fallot, critical pulmonary stenosis), left heart obstructive lesions (hypoplastic left heart, interrupted arch or coarctation, critical aortic stenosis), and mixing lesions (transposition, total anomalous pulmonary venous return, truncus arteriosus). Cyanosis with a systolic murmur and tachypnoea narrows that field considerably. The test questions then ask what you would order — pulse oximetry screening, echocardiography, chest radiography and ECG are the answers to give, with a reason for each. Pulse oximetry first is the answer most likely to be marked correct, because it is the screening test that triggers the rest of the pathway.

Question groupWhat it is really testingThe answer that fails
1-3: fetal structuresThree shunts and why pulmonary flow is reducedListing shunts without their purpose
4-7: cyanosis and tachypnoeaReasoning from a comparison between two babiesDefining cyanosis and stopping
8, 9, 16, 19: diagnosesA differential that narrows as signs accumulateThe same list repeated four times
11-15: heart soundsValve closure, turbulence, and murmur timingDescribing sounds without locating them
15: whirring between lub and dubSystolic timing as diagnostic informationCalling it 'an abnormal sound'
17, 20: investigationsTests chosen to discriminate between diagnosesOrdering everything available

Likely learning objectives

  • Explain fetal circulatory anatomy in terms of the function each shunt serves.
  • Revise a differential diagnosis as new clinical information is disclosed.
  • Use murmur timing and location as diagnostic data rather than description.
  • Select investigations that discriminate between competing diagnoses.

Assignment instructions

Read the full question

Review every instruction before using the planning guidance that follows.

Question 1 What are the major structural differences between the fetal and the adult human heart? Draw and label these differences on your diagram of the fetal heart. How do these structures alter the circulation of blood? Question 2 Why is the pulmonary circulation reduced in the human fetus? Question 3 Are heart rates of 130 to 160 normal in a human fetus? Question 4 What vital signs or symptoms do the two babies exhibit? Question 5 What is cyanosis? Question 6 Would you be alarmed that Brianna has cyanosis and Christopher does not? Why? Question 7 Why would the cyanotic baby have a faster breathing rate? Question 8 What are the possible diagnoses for Brianna’s condition at this time? For each diagnosis that you come up with, describe the signs or symptoms that relate to that diagnosis. Question 9 What are the possible diagnoses for Brianna’s condition at this time? For each diagnosis that you come up with, describe the signs or symptoms that relate to that diagnosis. Question 10 What additional signs or symptoms do the two babies exhibit? Question 11 What creates the lub heart sound? Question 12 What creates the dub heart sound? Question 13 What is a heart murmur? Question 14 Do murmurs have diff erent sounds and are they correlated with different problems? Question 15 What creates the whirring sound between the lub and the dub in Brianna’s heart? Question 16 What are the possible diagnoses for Brianna’s condition at this time? For each diagnosis that you come up with, describe the signs or symptoms that relate to that diagnosis. Question 17 If you were the pediatrician, what tests would you perform to help you narrow the possible diagnoses for Brianna’s condition? Question 18 What new signs or symptoms do the two babies exhibit? Question 19 What are the possible diagnoses for Brianna’s condition at this time? For each diagnosis that you come up with, describe the signs or symptoms that relate to that diagnosis. Question 20 If you were the pediatrician, what tests would you perform to help you narrow the possible diagnoses for Brianna’s condition? Question 21 What are the possible diagnoses for Brianna’s condition at this time? For each diagnosis that you come up with, describe the signs or symptoms that relate to that diagnosis. Try to think logically—sometimes the line of reasoning and the correct questions are more important than the answer. Question 22 Does a heart murmur necessarily indicate a dysfunctional valve? What other defects could produce the murmur heard through the stethoscope? Question 23 Does this diagnosis fit Brianna’s vital signs? Question 24 What created Brianna’s heart murmur? Question 25 Why is Brianna’s blood pressure lower than Christopher’s? Question 26 Why is Brianna’s blood pressure lower than Christopher’s? Question 27 Is it reasonable that Brianna’s arterial PO2 is the same as Christopher’s? Question 28 Why is Brianna breathing rapidly and deeply? Question 29 Do you think Brianna’s blood pressure is normal? Explain your answer. Question 30 Why is Brianna congested? Question 31 What is the long-term treatment for Brianna’s condition?

02

What the case study has to produce

  1. 01Answers to every numbered question in the case.
  2. 02A labelled diagram of the fetal heart showing the structural differences.
  3. 03An explanation of how those structures alter blood circulation.
  4. 04A differential diagnosis at each point it is requested, with supporting signs for each option.
  5. 05Investigations proposed, with a rationale for each.
03

From fetal shunts to a narrowing differential

01

Fetal versus adult cardiac anatomy

Set out the three shunts, the diagram, and the circulatory consequences.

What the assessor is likely looking for

Structures explained by the function they serve before birth.

02

Why pulmonary flow is low, and normal fetal heart rate

Connect fluid-filled lungs and high pulmonary resistance to the shunt pattern.

What the assessor is likely looking for

A mechanism rather than a restatement that the lungs are not in use.

03

Cyanosis, tachypnoea and the comparison between the babies

Define the sign, then reason from the difference between Brianna and Christopher.

What the assessor is likely looking for

The comparison treated as evidence, not as background colour.

04

Heart sounds and the murmur

Attribute the sounds, define a murmur, and place the whirring sound in the cycle.

What the assessor is likely looking for

Timing and location used to constrain the differential.

05

Iterated differentials and investigations

Give a revised differential at each disclosure point, then the tests that would separate them.

What the assessor is likely looking for

Visible narrowing across iterations, and tests chosen to discriminate.

04

Getting fetal circulation right before the diagnoses

Recommended databases

  • NCBI Bookshelf and StatPearls
  • PubMed
  • The course textbook's cardiovascular and development chapters

Search sequence

  1. 1.Get fetal circulation clear first, including what each shunt bypasses and why it closes after birth, because questions 1 to 3 are the foundation for every later answer.
  2. 2.Read a classification of critical congenital heart disease rather than individual defects, so your differential is organised by lesion type and can narrow systematically.
  3. 3.Look up murmur characteristics by lesion, so the whirring sound can be interpreted rather than merely noted.
  4. 4.Check the newborn screening and diagnostic pathway before answering the investigation questions, so the tests you propose are the ones actually used and in the order they are used.
05

Physiology and paediatric cardiology sources

These are authoritative starting points, not a ready-made bibliography. A qualified reviewer must confirm that each source fits the assignment and supports the claim beside which it is cited.

Physiology, Fetal Circulation - StatPearls

StatPearls Publishing, via NCBI Bookshelf · 2024

Review before citing

Answers questions 1 to 3 directly: the ductus venosus, foramen ovale and ductus arteriosus with what each bypasses, why pulmonary resistance is high before the first breath, and a normal fetal heart rate range of 110-160. It also explains how each shunt closes after birth, which is the background against which a persistent shunt becomes pathological.

Cyanotic Heart Disease - StatPearls - NCBI Bookshelf

StatPearls Publishing, via NCBI Bookshelf · 2024

Review before citing

The classification your differential should be built on — right heart obstructive lesions, left heart obstructive lesions, and mixing lesions — with the presenting features the case is disclosing to you: cyanosis, tachypnoea, feeding difficulty, poor perfusion and murmur. This is what turns four repeated differential questions into a narrowing sequence.

Tetralogy of Fallot - StatPearls - NCBI Bookshelf

StatPearls Publishing, via NCBI Bookshelf · 2024

Review before citing

The most likely single diagnosis to appear in this differential, and a worked example of linking a murmur to a lesion: a harsh systolic ejection murmur at the left mid-to-upper sternal border whose intensity tracks obstruction severity. Its four anatomical features also give you a model for describing signs alongside each candidate diagnosis, as the question requires.

06

Before the case study is handed in

Common mistakes

  • Giving the same differential at questions 8, 9, 16 and 19 instead of narrowing it as signs appear.
  • Ignoring the phrase 'at this time', which is what makes the repeated question a different question.
  • Naming the fetal shunts without saying what each one bypasses and why.
  • Explaining reduced pulmonary circulation without reference to high pulmonary vascular resistance.
  • Defining cyanosis without reasoning about why one twin has it and the other does not.
  • Describing heart sounds without attributing them to specific valve closures.
  • Treating the whirring sound as an unclassified abnormality rather than a systolic murmur.
  • Listing every available test rather than choosing tests that discriminate.

Submission checklist

  • All three fetal shunts are named with their function.
  • The diagram is labelled and matches the written answer.
  • The fetal heart rate question is answered with a stated normal range.
  • Each differential is narrower than the one before it, with a reason.
  • Every diagnosis offered has its supporting signs listed.
  • Both heart sounds are attributed to valve closures.
  • The murmur is placed in the cardiac cycle and interpreted.
  • Proposed tests each carry a rationale.

Use this guide to plan and review your own work. Follow your institution's rules and read Brinevia's academic-integrity policy.

Written by

Everett Voss

MA, Education

assignment interpretation and research-methods coaching across disciplines

Everett leads the Brinevia editorial desk. He works on how assignment briefs are read — what a rubric is actually asking for, and where students most often answer a different question than the one set.

Reviewed by

Dr. Julian Merriweather

PhD, Rhetoric & Composition

Argumentation and thesis development

Julian teaches first-year composition and directs a university writing center. He reviews Brinevia guides for argumentative soundness and citation accuracy.

Want feedback on your plan before you draft?

Get help interpreting the brief, checking your evidence strategy, and strengthening your outline while keeping the work your own.

Get assignment guidance
Start your order