New here? Get 15% off your first order.See how it works

Nursing questions
Discussion postPatient privacy

Addressing Ethical Issues

The NUR 514 Topic 7 DQ 2 discussion post: one ethical and one legal issue with electronic health records that directly affect advanced registered nursing practice, the consequences of compromising patient data, and what you personally do to protect privacy. This guide shows how to keep the ethical and legal halves genuinely distinct.

Editorial process

Last reviewed · August 7, 2026

01

One of each, and why that is a constraint

Eighty-two words of prompt containing four separate requirements, and the discipline this needs is subtraction rather than coverage. **One** ethical issue and **one** legal issue is a constraint, not a floor: a post that lists four of each has less to say about any of them, and the marker is looking for depth in a format that has no room for breadth. Then two more things that are easy to lose in a post that spends its length on the first two — the consequences of compromising patient data, and measures **you** can implement in your **own** practice. That last possessive is doing work. It rules out a paragraph about what the organisation's IT department should encrypt and asks what you personally do differently at a workstation. Write the four answers as four short moves and the length looks after itself, since a discussion post has no room for structure that is not doing work.

The distinction most posts collapse is the one the question is built on. A legal issue is one where a rule is breached and an authority can act: unauthorised access, disclosure beyond the minimum necessary, failure to notify after a breach. An ethical issue is one where the law is silent or fully satisfied and the right course is still contested. That is why snooping in a record makes a poor ethical example — it is simply illegal, so using it for both halves answers one question twice. Stronger ethical choices are the ones HIPAA permits: copy-forward documentation that makes a note technically accurate and clinically misleading, overriding decision support that is contraindicated for your particular patient, or secondary use of record data for analytics the patient never contemplated when they consented to treatment.

The clause *directly impact advanced registered nursing practice* is the one that separates a strong post from a generic one, and it should shape both choices. The issue you pick has to attach to what an APRN specifically does — prescribing and e-prescribing, ordering diagnostics, carrying an independent panel, signing documentation that another clinician relies on, exercising judgement against a clinical decision support recommendation. An issue that would read identically for a unit secretary has not met the condition. This is also the natural place to note that the APRN is often the accountable signature on a record they did not fully author, which makes documentation integrity a professional exposure rather than an administrative one. The simplest test is to reread your chosen issue and ask whether a unit secretary could face it too; if they could, the prompt's central qualifier has gone unanswered and the post reads as generic informatics commentary.

Consequences reward specificity and tiering, because the vague version — 'there can be serious consequences' — is what most posts settle for. Civil monetary penalties under the HITECH structure scale with culpability, from a violation the entity did not know about through wilful neglect that was never corrected. Criminal liability exists separately for knowing disclosure, with the ceiling reserved for disclosure for personal gain or malicious harm. The Office for Civil Rights can impose a corrective action plan with monitoring. And then the one nurses consistently omit: a privacy breach is reportable to the state board and can end a licence, which is a career consequence entirely separate from anything the employer does. Name at least the regulatory, the professional and the employment layer. Naming three layers costs a sentence each and it is the difference between issuing a warning and describing how enforcement actually works.

For measures in your own practice, concrete beats comprehensive. Never work under another clinician's credentials and never lend yours; log out rather than lock and walk; apply minimum necessary when you query rather than opening the whole chart because you can; verify identity before releasing anything by phone; keep protected health information out of text messages and personal email; use the documented break-the-glass workflow when emergency access is genuinely needed, because it creates the audit trail that protects you. And say plainly that you do not look up family members, colleagues or yourself, which is the single most common reason nurses are terminated for a privacy violation and is almost always motivated by concern rather than malice. Each of these is something you would do differently tomorrow, which is the test the prompt's wording sets and the reason a list beats a paragraph of principle.

What the prompt asksThe common postWhat earns the mark
One ethical issueA list of severalOne issue where the law is satisfied and the answer is still contested
One legal issueSnooping, used for bothA distinct breach of a specific rule
Impact on APRN practiceGeneral EHR commentaryPrescribing, ordering, decision support, accountable signature
ConsequencesThey can be seriousRegulatory penalties, board action, employment
Measures in your own practiceThe facility should encrypt dataCredentials, minimum necessary, break-the-glass, no family lookups

Likely learning objectives

  • Separate a legal violation from an ethical dilemma the law does not resolve.
  • Tie an informatics issue to the specific scope of advanced practice.
  • Describe consequences across regulatory, professional and employment layers.
  • Translate a privacy principle into an individual behaviour at the workstation.

Assignment instructions

Read the full question

Review every instruction before using the planning guidance that follows.

NUR 514 Topic 7 DQ 2 Discuss one ethical and one legal issue related to the use of EHRs that directly impact advanced registered nursing practice. Review HIPAA protected health information (PHI), and requirements for privacy and confidentiality in EHRs. Discuss one ethical and one legal issue related to the use of EHRs that directly impact advanced registered nursing practice. Discuss possible consequences for compromising patient data and measures you can implement in your own practice to protect patient privacy and confidentiality.

02

What the post has to cover

  1. 01One ethical issue related to EHR use in advanced registered nursing practice.
  2. 02One legal issue related to EHR use in advanced registered nursing practice.
  3. 03Possible consequences for compromising patient data.
  4. 04Measures you can implement in your own practice to protect privacy and confidentiality.
03

Building the post in four moves

01

Name the legal issue and the rule it breaks

A specific requirement — minimum necessary, authorised access, breach notification — and how EHRs create the exposure.

What the assessor is likely looking for

A legal issue anchored to an actual obligation.

02

Name an ethical issue the law permits

Copy-forward documentation, overriding contraindicated decision support, or secondary use of record data.

What the assessor is likely looking for

A genuine dilemma rather than a second legal example.

03

Attach both to advanced practice

Prescribing, ordering, independent panels, and being the accountable signature on a shared record.

What the assessor is likely looking for

The clause the prompt adds and most posts drop.

04

Tier the consequences

Civil penalties scaled by culpability, criminal liability for knowing disclosure, corrective action plans, board discipline, termination.

What the assessor is likely looking for

Specific consequences rather than a warning.

05

List what you personally do

Credentials, logging out, minimum necessary querying, identity verification, no PHI in messaging, documented emergency access.

What the assessor is likely looking for

Practice you control, in the first person.

06

Close on the family and colleague lookup

The commonest real-world violation, and the one motivated by concern rather than malice.

What the assessor is likely looking for

Insight into how breaches actually happen.

04

Reading the rule before citing it

Recommended databases

  • HHS Office for Civil Rights HIPAA guidance
  • OJIN, the Online Journal of Issues in Nursing
  • CINAHL
  • PubMed

Search sequence

  1. 1.Read the HIPAA requirement you intend to cite in its own words rather than in a summary, since the legal half of the post rests on it.
  2. 2.Find nursing-specific literature on EHR ethics, so the ethical half is grounded in the profession rather than in general bioethics.
  3. 3.Check your own state board's disciplinary actions for privacy violations, which supplies the licensure consequence.
  4. 4.Look up the breach notification thresholds and timelines if you use breach as your legal issue.
05

Nursing EHR ethics and the HIPAA requirements

These are authoritative starting points, not a ready-made bibliography. A qualified reviewer must confirm that each source fits the assignment and supports the claim beside which it is cited.

Identifying and Addressing Ethical Issues with Use of Electronic Health Records

OJIN: The Online Journal of Issues in Nursing, American Nurses Association · 2018

Review before citing

McBride and colleagues on the ethical issues nurses actually raise about EHRs, with a case scenario worked through an ethical decision-making model. The best single source for the ethical half, because it keeps the discussion inside nursing practice rather than in general informatics.

Breach Notification Rule

Office for Civil Rights, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services · 2026

Review before citing

What counts as a breach, who must be notified, and within what timeframe. Use it if breach notification is your legal issue, and for the regulatory layer of the consequences section, where the obligation to notify is itself part of the cost.

Minimum Necessary Requirement

Office for Civil Rights, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services · 2026

Review before citing

The standard that makes opening more of a chart than you need a violation rather than a habit. This is the rule behind several of the personal measures, so citing it turns that section from a list of good practice into applied regulation.

06

Before the post goes up

Common mistakes

  • Listing several issues instead of the one of each that was asked for.
  • Using unauthorised access as both the ethical and the legal example.
  • Choosing an issue that would apply identically to any hospital employee.
  • Describing consequences only as 'serious' or 'costly'.
  • Omitting state board action from the consequences.
  • Answering the practice-measures question with organisational IT controls.
  • Defining HIPAA at length instead of applying it.
  • Citing no scholarly source in a post that requires APA references.

Submission checklist

  • Exactly one ethical issue is developed.
  • Exactly one legal issue is developed, and it is not the same problem restated.
  • Both are tied to what an advanced practice nurse specifically does.
  • Consequences cover regulatory, professional licensure and employment.
  • The measures are individual actions, not organisational controls.
  • At least one measure addresses access to records of people you know.
  • HIPAA terms are applied rather than defined.
  • Sources are cited in APA format per the course requirement.

Use this guide to plan and review your own work. Follow your institution's rules and read Brinevia's academic-integrity policy.

Written by

Everett Voss

MA, Education

assignment interpretation and research-methods coaching across disciplines

Everett leads the Brinevia editorial desk. He works on how assignment briefs are read — what a rubric is actually asking for, and where students most often answer a different question than the one set.

Reviewed by

Dr. Julian Merriweather

PhD, Rhetoric & Composition

Argumentation and thesis development

Julian teaches first-year composition and directs a university writing center. He reviews Brinevia guides for argumentative soundness and citation accuracy.

Want feedback on your plan before you draft?

Get help interpreting the brief, checking your evidence strategy, and strengthening your outline while keeping the work your own.

Get assignment guidance
Start your order